historians.social is one of the many independent Mastodon servers you can use to participate in the fediverse.
Historians.social is open to all who are interested in history.

Server stats:

228
active users

As you may be able to tell, our class has now reached the era of the

So, continuing our exploration of student (as always: descriptive, not prescriptive!):

1) As I expected, "Battleship Potemkin" was something completely new to them. They were suitably moved by the famous scene on the Odessa steps

archive.org/details/Battleship

(but why I did I first have to admonish a couple of them focused on their laptops or phones to turn toward the screen? WTF)

1/n

If "Battleship Potemkin" meant nothing to our students, then they were certainly not aware of Eisenstein's great "October," either.

youtube.com/watch?v=k62eaN9-TL

I hinted that, when their cultural tastes had further matured, I might at last introduce them to

"Aelita Queen of Mars" (1924) 🙃

imdb.com/title/tt0014646/plots

youtu.be/yoROo4Ur49c

3/n

But back to issues of students' cultural literacy, for lack of a better term (as noted, always descriptive rather than prescriptive)

Today, re: Bolshevik Revolution

One had an idea of housing blocks & monumental architecture

The rest: pretty much: 0

I noted opinion polls showing that students/young people had more positive views of socialism vs. capitalism--which I found interesting insofar as they had 0 knowledge of Marxism, socialist theory, revolutionary history

All instructive!

4/n

@CitizenWald They have an intimate knowledge of capitalism, though.

Jim Wald

@aristofontes

Indeed! As I told them, though, historical context varies:

Today: shitloads of college debt, prospect they won't live quite as well as their parents

Back then: my grandfather got shitloads of banknotes, filled a wheelbarrow, and rushed to the bakery before they had lost half their value.

Or: some years later: went without work and pay.

(Of course, I also talked to them about long-term structural and cyclical issues and validated the importance of subjective experience)